The do’s and don’ts of a NAS

The do’s and don’ts of a NAS

 

A Network Attached Storage, or NAS for short, is popular with many residential users. Not surprisingly, we regularly get the question whether storage of data for backup and/or archive can also ‘just’ be done on a NAS. That question is not very easy to answer.

NAS and SAN

For professional use, you have to look at a so-called “Enterprise NAS” anyway, because a “private” NAS is not adequate for professional use in almost all cases. But first, take a look at NAS and SAN. NAS stands for Network Attached Storage, SAN for Storage Area Network. Often users have the perception that a NAS is for home use and a SAN is for businesses. But that’s not the difference. The difference is in how you access data on these systems. A NAS has a network connection and you access it like a “regular” hard drive. You write and retrieve files from the NAS and the NAS takes care of the rest. This is different with a SAN: files are not written to a SAN, but blocks of the files distributed somewhere on the SAN. The operating system is responsible for turning the blocks back into a file. In a nutshell, a NAS is file storage and a SAN is block storage.

Speed and flexibility

For the user, it makes no difference because the translation of files to blocks is done on a server, which manages the SAN. This storage server has the choice of how to handle the files and convert them into blocks. With a NAS, the NAS must ensure that the files exist; with a SAN, the server does that. This means that a SAN has far fewer administrative tasks than a NAS and can therefore be much faster and more flexible. For secondary storage, a NAS is fine because it usually does not need that speed. Technically, cloud storage is also à la NAS: you send files over the network for storage, and how that happens is up to the cloud provider.

Why yes/no?

But what are the snags in using an inexpensive NAS for professional use? Suppliers of a low-cost NAS for, say, 120 terabytes gross, do so by putting in 10 12-terabyte drives. Those disks are relatively cheap per terabyte and so the price can be driven down. The fact is, however, that a large hard drive breaks down at least as quickly as a small hard drive. If such a disk fails, you have to recover the 12 terabytes of data lost. That can take 6 to 12 weeks! If a second hard drive fails during that period, you really have a problem. That probability is greater the longer the rebuildtime. You would therefore build a comparable Enterprise NAS from 60 2 terabyte hard drives, but then it becomes costly.

Compare

The well-known Silent Bricks and Silent Cubes also technically work like a NAS and are also comparable in price to a NAS that works with hard drives. However, the Silent Bricks and Silent Cubes offer much more flexibility and safety. For home use, a NAS is a great way to store data, but for professional use we still recommend a different solution!

Webinar: European storage and digital sovereignty

On Thursday, Sept. 11 at 12:00 p.m., we’ll show you how to stay in control of your data in an era of cloud dependency and stricter regulations (such as NIS2, GDPR and DORA). Discover why European storage is crucial, how to mitigate risk with Zero Loss storage and what you can do today to stay compliant and future-proof. Don’t miss anything and register now.

Subscribe for tips and info

We regularly write blogs on current topics from the world of digital storage technology. Sign up here to be notified about new blogs.